The UK Government's EU Withdrawal Bill has two major flaws which make it "fatal" to devolution, Scotland's Brexit Minister has said.

Michael Russell told MPs the proposed legislation "breaks the devolution understanding that what is not reserved is devolved" and would enable UK Ministers to make alterations to Scottish legislation without scrutiny at Holyrood.

The Bill to transpose EU law into British law involves responsibilities in devolved areas being initially transferred to Westminster, resulting in the Scottish and Welsh administrations joining together to refuse to grant consent to the bill as it stands.

Loading article content

Giving evidence to Westminster's Scottish Affairs Committee on the impact of the Bill on devolution, Russell said: "We and the Welsh have taken the position on two issues which we believe are fatal to devolution."

He said if legislative amendments are made to address these two areas the Scottish Government would bring forward a legislative consent motion which it believes the Scottish Parliament would support, and currently all parties at Holyrood are involved in talks on the issue.

He added: "We don't have a solution as yet, within the Scottish Parliament to that, but we are talking and we are also talking to the UK Government to try and find a way to overcome what are we believe fatal flaws in the Bill as far as devolution is concerned.

"The reason there is that cooperation is because this is not about the SNP and it's not about a single party. It is about devolution which all the parties have made work over the last 20 years.

"I think that's the key issue. No matter what position you take on the big questions in Scottish Politics, all the parties work together to make devolution work and to make the parliament work.

"We believe this bill contains things that would make that much more difficult and would reduce the ability of the parliament to serve the people of Scotland."

Liberal Democrat Christine Jardine asked the minister: "There is a contradiction between being quite happy to work within that European framework but when the powerbase moves to Westminster it's not acceptable, so could you explain the difference?"

Russell denied this is the case and said decisions taken in the European Union were co-decisions but said there is no proposal in the EU Withdrawal Bill for this, adding that EU frameworks were discussed, not imposed.

He continued: "This Bill decides to override devolution."