BEST question: Ross asking FM why computers not delivered to pupils at very start of pandemic.

Best reply: Slater refuting claim there “is no money” for economic recovery by referring to cash being spent on new nuclear weapons.

First to mention Salmond: Willie Rennie.

Second to refer to Salmond: Willie Rennie.

Most radical offer: FM says she’ll “explore” four-day working week – but nobody seemed to notice.

Most cringeworthy reference: Ross mentioning his “wee boy”. Second most cringeworthy point: Ross telling us how he volunteered to help with covid vaccinations.

Best newcomer: brainy engineer Lorna Slater of the Greens – just needs to learn not to shout at the camera.

READ MORE: Anas Sarwar and Douglas Ross clash in battle for second spot in Holyrood

Cool under fire: the FM as always.

Most down to earth: amazingly, Willie Rennie.

Audience member asked if he’d vote Alba: “No, I’m an engineer. I’m voting Green”.

Hollowest promise: Ross offering better broadband in next parliament. It’s a reserved matter, Douglas, and when I last looked Conservatives had been in power for over a decade!

On top of their policy brief: Anas Sarwar.

WATCH: Anas Sarwar tells Douglas Ross told to 'grow up' at BBC leaders' debate

Audience performance: stilted – Zoom format destroys all the drama.

Prize for obsessive mentions of indyref: Douglas Ross (no surprise there).

Overall perception: apart from the constitution, amazing how similar all five policy propositions were – liberalism, reflation, mental health, skills – more a debate over who could actually deliver.

Who lost? Ross came across like a schoolboy – lacks gravitas or policy focus.

Wille Rennie seemed jovial but wholly irrelevant to what was going on.

Slater is impressive but could not land a real hit.

READ MORE: Lesley Riddoch: Why BBC were the real losers at Scottish leaders' debate

Who won? Sarwar came across like a determined prosecution lawyer.

Rating out of 10: Sarah Smith (-1), Ross (1), Willie Rennie (4), Slater (6), Sarwar (8), FM (8).

Guess the catchphrase: “I leave it to others to judge…”